Heavy Taxes and Empty Pockets [What's in a Word?]

Written by RC Klein, 25/7/2019

 Heavy Taxes and Empty Pockets

The Bible uses two Hebrew words for taxes: mas (or missim in plural) and meches. In this essay, we will explore the etymology and meanings of these two words. Afterwards, we will discuss the three Aramaic words found in to mean tax: minda, belo, and halach; and three more Aramaic words in the Talmud: kargaarnona, and taska. We will also trace the etymologies of those words and, in doing so, we will hone in on their exact meanings.

Rabbi Shlomo Pappenheim of Breslau (17401814) offers three possibly etymologies for the Hebrew word mas. Firstly, in his work Yerios Shlomo, he suggests that the root of mas is the letter SAMECH alone, which denotes rejection and disassociation. Other words derived from this root include nas (fleeing), and maus (disgusting). He connects taxes to rejection and disassociation because when one pays taxes, he disassociates himself from that money and gives it over to the authorities.

Secondly, in his work Cheshek Shlomo, Rabbi Pappenheim proposes that the root of mas is MEM-SAMECH, which means melting or disintegrating. He explains that this refers to taxes because they melt away ones assets and cause them disintegrate.

Thirdly, Rabbi Pappenheim (also in Cheshek Shlomo) explains that the word mas is derived from the root SIN-ALEPH (sa), which refers to carrying or lifting. This is relevant to taxes because they represent a burden which one must carry. Interestingly, according to theOxford English Dictionary, the noun tax has two definitions: a compulsory contribution to state revenue and a strain or heavy demand. If Rabbi Pappenheim is right, the second meaning is actually the basis for the first.

Although mas is typically translated as tax, some scholars argue that a more accurate translation would be corvée work, that is, a system of compulsory, unpaid labor or civil service imposed by a sovereign. This meaning of forced labor is borne out by the Bible in several places. For example, the Torah terms the Egyptian taskmasters who oversaw the enslaved Jews as sarei missim  Officers of Missim [the plural of mas] (Ex. 1:11). Similarly, when King Solomon instituted mandatory conscription of civilians, this levy was called a mas(I Kgs. 5:27).

The other Biblical Hebrew word which sometimes means tax is meches. It appears six times in the Bible in that sense, with all instanced clustered in one chapter (Num. 31:2841). In that context, meches refers to the consecrated booty from the Jews war against the Midianites, which was to be given to G-d.

Dr. Hayim Tawil of Yeshiva University argues that the Biblical Hebrew meches is actually a loanword from the Akkadian miksu (dues or tributes), which is derived from the Akkadian verb makasu (to collect a share from a rented field, to collect taxes, duty). However, others have found a Hebrew basis for that word.

Menachem ibn Saruk (920970) identifies the root of meches as KAF-SAMECH, while Rabbi Yehudah ibn Chayyuj (), Rabbi Yonah ibn Janach (9901050), and Rabbi David Kimchi (11601235)also known as Radakwrite that its root is KAF-SAMECH-SAMECH. Either way, these roots mean number, which explains how meches was borrowed to mean tax whose rate is usually a function of numbers.

Rabbi Pappenheim agrees that the root of meches is KAF-SAMECH, but argues that the core meaning of KAF-SAMECH is not number, but covering. Another word with the same root  kis (pocket) is a covered space into which one puts small items, like coins, to avoid losing them. Thus, the related word meches refers specifically to the type of tax which ends up in the kings pocket/purse (as opposed to other taxes which are used for public works). In the case of the Jewish People, that King is G-d, to whom the meches is given.

[The above-cited grammarians point to the Hebrew word michsat (Ex. 12:4) used to describe the number of individuals collectively offering a single Paschal Lamb as evidence that the root KAF-SAMECH means number. However, Rabbi Pappenheim argues that that too is merely a borrowed usage. He explains that michsat refers to the idea that multiple people pool their money into single pot or pocket to purchase the sacrifice.]

Now let us examine the Aramaic words for tax. The Bible uses these three words when it reports that Cyrus, king of Persia, issued a special exemption releasing the Men of the Great Assembly from paying taxes. They were released from paying minda, belo, and halach (Ezra 7:24)all Aramaic words.

Rabbi Baruch Avraham Toledano (1825-1917) writes that minda is related to the Hebrew word middah ("measure" or "dimension") as it was the fee imposed was a function of the measurement of ones property. Belo is an expression of wearing out and refers to food which gets digested and "worn out". And halach is related to the word holech ("walking" or "travelling"), and refers to taxes used for the upkeep of transportation infrastructure like public roads and bridges.

The Talmud (Bava Basra 8a and Nedarim 62b) explains that minda refers to the kings portion (manat hamelech). This seems to be the Aramaic equivalent of meches (as explained by R. Pappenheim), i.e. a tax for the kings personal profit.

The second term used in the verse is belo, which the Talmud (there) explains refers togulgalta money. As is evident from the ensuing discussion in the Talmud, the term gulgaltameans the same thing as karga. The Aramaic word karga (derived from the Persian karakaand/or Arabic harag) refers to a poll tax or head tax, which was a fixed sum that each individual was obligated to pay (see Rashi to Bava Metzia 73b). The word gulgalta is actually an Aramicization of the Hebrew word gulgolet (skull), as the capitation tax applied to each individual (i.e. head).

The Talmud explains that the third term in the verse, halach, means arnona, which was a crop tax levied on farmers. Rashi (to Pesachim 6a, Bava Basra 8a) explains that arnonaentailed paying the government a tenth of ones animals and grain every year. In fact, historians record that in the Roman Empire, there was a tax called annona which was used to supply grain and other foodstuffs to the city of Rome. Annona was derived from the Latin word annus (year, the source of the English word annual), because it was calculated from the sum total of the years harvests.

Alternatively, Rabbi Nosson of Rome in Sefer HaAruch explains that arnona was a meal that each city had to supply to the king or army when they traveled (i.e. halach  go) through that city. Rabbeinu Nissim (to Nedarim 62b) offers two ways of fitting this explanation to the word arnona. First, he writes that arnona is Greek for meal. Second, he writes that arnonameans partnership, just like we find that the River Arnon was the border between the Moabites and Emorites (Num. 21:13), effectively joining those two territories. These two explanations are also cited by Maharam Chalavah and Meiri (to Pesachim 6a).

There is another Talmudic term for tax, namely taska, meaning property tax (see Rashi toGittin 58b, Bava Metzia 73b, 108a). Elsewhere, taska means sack (Rashi to Megillah 7b) or basket (Tosafos to Avodah Zarah 14b), so it seems that its use as a word for property tax is simply a borrowed meaning. In Modern Hebrew, taska is replaced with arnona, which has been redefined to mean property tax. Likewise, in Modern Hebrew, mas is the generic word for tax, while meches refers specifically to customs tax.

We thus have many words which mean tax: mas and meches in Biblical Hebrew; and minda,belo, and halach in Biblical Aramaic; and gulgalta, karga, arnona, and taska in Talmudic Aramaic.    

final-logo.png

I was recently a guest on the Holy Madness podcast at https://holymadness.org/ 

We discussed such important topics as why elephants have such good memory, how often it snows in Egypt, and the medicinal uses of hemlock. We also spoke about such things as how to deal with Bible Criticism from an Orthodox Jewish perspective, whether or not Hinduism is considered Avodah Zarah, and why everyone should buy a copy of my book

It's a long show (2 hours), but it's really fun and informative! Check it out here!

Kol Tuv,

Reuven Chaim Klein

Beitar Illit, Israel

To dedicate this Chiddush (Free!) Leiluy Nishmas,Refuah Sheleimah, Hatzlacha, click here


Agree? Disagree? Want to add anything? Comment on the chiddush!
Discussions - Answers and Comments (0)
This chiddush has not been commented on yet